Back to Cases
Unsolved April 24, 1891 Homicide

Carrie Brown

Status Unsolved
Type Homicide
Date April 24, 1891
Location New York City, New York
Victim Age 56
Gender Female

Carrie Brown, a prostitute known as 'Old Shakespeare,' was found murdered and mutilated in her New York City hotel room. She was initially suspected as a Jack the Ripper copycat victim but the timing didn't align. Ameer Ben Ali was convicted but pardoned after 11 years. The actual killer was never conclusively identified.

Carrie Brown is documented in the ColdCaseIndex database as a homicide case in New York City, New York. The events are dated to April 24, 1891. The victim is recorded as 56 years old and female. The last known information on record places the case at April 24, 1891, East River Hotel, New York City.

Within the ColdCaseIndex taxonomy, Carrie Brown is filed under Homicide with a status of Unsolved. A homicide entry documents a killing in which the perpetrator has not been identified, has not been convicted, or where the case is otherwise historically notable. The record is cross-referenced under the themes homicide, historical, New York, Jack the Ripper copycat, unsolved, 1891, which connect it to related cases across the database.

As of the most recent information compiled here, no arrest has been publicly recorded in the Carrie Brown case, and it remains open and unsolved. Cases like this can be reactivated at any time — advances in DNA analysis, forensic genetic genealogy, and renewed public attention have resolved cases that lay dormant for decades.

Primary jurisdiction for the Carrie Brown case rests with local law enforcement in New York City, supported by New York state investigative authorities. The case sits within a wider national picture: the U.S. homicide clearance rate has fallen from roughly 90% in the 1960s to about 54% today, and more than 346,000 homicides recorded since 1965 remain unsolved. ColdCaseIndex documents individual cases like this one to keep them publicly visible and searchable.

homicide historical New York Jack the Ripper copycat unsolved 1891
Last Known Information
April 24, 1891, East River Hotel, New York City
Date of Incident
April 24, 1891
Current Status
Unsolved — the case remains open

Curated starting points for verifying and researching this case. Direct references are checked; search links are provided as further-reading aids. ColdCaseIndex is an index of public information — see a case correction? Email info@coldcaseindex.com.

Have Information About This Case?

Cold cases are solved when someone comes forward. Even a detail that seems minor can matter. If you have any information about this case, contact law enforcement through one of these channels:

  • FBI Tips (tips.fbi.gov) — submit a tip online to the Federal Bureau of Investigation
  • FBI Tip Line: 1-800-CALL-FBI (1-800-225-5324)
  • The local police department or sheriff's office in New York, or the state bureau of investigation

Tips can usually be submitted anonymously. To report an error on this page, email info@coldcaseindex.com.