Skip to content
ColdCaseIndex
StatisticsBy StateBy TypeSerial KillersBy DecadeMapAnalysisAbout
Home›Cases by decade›1890s

Cold Cases of the 1890s

2 documented cases in which the crime or disappearance took place between 1890 and 1899. 2 are recorded as unsolved.

Serial killers of the 1890s
Status of the 2 cases
  • Unsolved 2 (100%)

By type

1 Homicides1 Multiple Homicides

All 2 cases

Unsolved 1892

Andrew & Abby Borden

Andrew Borden and his wife Abby were found hacked to death in their Fall River, Massachusetts home. Their daughter Lizzie was acquitted of the murders.

Massachusetts Multiple Homicide
Unsolved 1891

Carrie Brown

Carrie Brown, known on the Bowery as "Old Shakespeare," was found strangled and mutilated in Room 31 of the East River Hotel in Manhattan on April 24, 1891.

New York Homicide Age 56

Other decades

2 1880s2 1890s3 1900s6 1910s6 1920s8 1930s9 1940s12 1950s48 1960s87 1970s130 1980s117 1990s137 2000s153 2010s68 2020sCases by decade
ColdCaseIndex

A searchable database of documented cold cases and historic crimes, compiled from public records and cited reporting.

Browse

All cases By state By type By decade By theme By city Serial killers Case map Analysis Recent updates Cases to watch On this day

Site

About & methodology Privacy Report a correction

Data sources

Murder Accountability Project NamUs The Charley Project

© 2026 ColdCaseIndex. A research resource for public interest.

Contact: info@coldcaseindex.com