Conviction November 20, 1901 Homicide

Nell Cropsey

Nineteen-year-old Ella Maud 'Nell' Cropsey disappeared from her family's home beside the Pasquotank River in Elizabeth City, North Carolina, in November 1901; her body was found in the river on December 27. Her former suitor Jim Wilcox was convicted of second-degree murder in 1903 and later pardoned by Governor Thomas Bickett.

Status
Conviction
Type
Homicide
Date
November 20, 1901
Location
Elizabeth City, North Carolina
Age
19
Gender
Female
Decade
1900s
Where the case stands
  1. Open
  2. Partly resolved
  3. Charges or trial
  4. ClosedConviction

At least one person was convicted in connection with the case.

Timeline to scale
Each dot is a dated event below; the distance between dots is elapsed time. The darker dot marks the incident.
June 1898: Nell Cropsey meets Jim Wilcox, the year her family settles in Elizabeth City.November 20, 1901: Nell Cropsey is last seen late at night after walking Wilcox out of her family home.December 27, 1901: Her body is found in the Pasquotank River near the family home; Wilcox is charged with murder.March 1902: In Pasquotank County, Wilcox is convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to death.September 30, 1902: The North Carolina Supreme Court orders a new trial because of courtroom demonstrations.1903: At a retrial in Perquimans County, Wilcox is convicted of second-degree murder and sentenced to 30 years.December 20, 1920: Governor Thomas Bickett pardons Wilcox (some sources give 1918).1934: Jim Wilcox dies by suicide in Elizabeth City.18981901193432 years from incident to latest development
North Carolina
7 cases in North Carolina. Select any state to browse its cases.
AlaskaAKMaineMEWisconsinWIVermontVTNew HampshireNHWashingtonWAIdahoIDMontanaMTNorth DakotaNDMinnesotaMNIllinoisILMichiganMINew YorkNYMassachusettsMAOregonORNevadaNVWyomingWYSouth DakotaSDIowaIAIndianaINOhioOHPennsylvaniaPANew JerseyNJConnecticutCTRhode IslandRICaliforniaCAUtahUTColoradoCONebraskaNEMissouriMOKentuckyKYWest VirginiaWVVirginiaVAMarylandMDDelawareDEArizonaAZNew MexicoNMKansasKSArkansasARTennesseeTNNorth CarolinaNCSouth CarolinaSCDistrict of ColumbiaDCOklahomaOKLouisianaLAMississippiMSAlabamaALGeorgiaGAHawaiiHITexasTXFloridaFL

Ella Maud 'Nell' Cropsey lived with her family close to the Pasquotank River in Elizabeth City, North Carolina. According to the North Carolina Supreme Court's 1903 opinion in State v. Wilcox, her father W. H. Cropsey had moved the family to the town in 1898, and she was 19 at the time of her death. That same year she met James 'Jim' Wilcox, who courted her for about three years, according to material published by DigitalNC and the Museum of the Albemarle.

On the night of November 20, 1901, Nell walked Wilcox out of the family home at around 11:10 p.m. and was not seen again, according to the DigitalNC summary. Coastal Review reports that she ended the relationship during that conversation on the porch and that Wilcox said he left her there. Some accounts, including a 2016 blog post by the North Carolina Department of Natural and Cultural Resources, give the date of her disappearance as November 21.

Her body was found on the surface of the Pasquotank River near her home on December 27, 1901, about 37 days after she vanished. According to Coastal Review, the autopsy found a bruise on her left temple and reported that her lungs contained no water. Accounts of the coroner's findings cite both a blow to the head and drowning, and the medical experts did not agree on which caused her death.

Wilcox was charged with murder. At the March 1902 term of court in Pasquotank County he was found guilty of first-degree murder and sentenced to death. The North Carolina Supreme Court ordered a new trial after disruptive demonstrations in and around the courtroom during the defense's closing argument. The case was moved to Perquimans County, and at the 1903 retrial in Hertford Wilcox was convicted of second-degree murder and sentenced to 30 years in prison, according to Coastal Review and other accounts.

Earlier petitions for clemency were denied. Governor Thomas Bickett eventually pardoned Wilcox after receiving a letter from him in which he maintained his innocence. Sources disagree on the year of the pardon: DigitalNC and some other accounts give 1918, while the Department of Natural and Cultural Resources and other accounts give December 1920. Wilcox returned to Elizabeth City and died by suicide in 1934.

The case remains a well-known piece of northeastern North Carolina history. Writers and researchers have proposed several explanations for Nell Cropsey's death, and at least one author has argued that Wilcox was wrongly convicted, according to the Museum of the Albemarle materials described by DigitalNC.

  1. June 1898
    Nell Cropsey meets Jim Wilcox, the year her family settles in Elizabeth City.
  2. November 20, 1901
    Nell Cropsey is last seen late at night after walking Wilcox out of her family home.
  3. December 27, 1901
    Her body is found in the Pasquotank River near the family home; Wilcox is charged with murder.
  4. March 1902
    In Pasquotank County, Wilcox is convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to death.
  5. September 30, 1902
    The North Carolina Supreme Court orders a new trial because of courtroom demonstrations.
  6. 1903
    At a retrial in Perquimans County, Wilcox is convicted of second-degree murder and sentenced to 30 years.
  7. December 20, 1920
    Governor Thomas Bickett pardons Wilcox (some sources give 1918).
  8. 1934
    Jim Wilcox dies by suicide in Elizabeth City.

About this entry

This case is recorded as conviction and is kept in the index for its historical and investigative significance. At least one person was convicted in connection with the case.

To report an error on this page, email info@coldcaseindex.com.

Entry last updated November 4, 2026.

Cite this entry

Permalink: https://coldcaseindex.com/cases/nell-cropsey-1901/. This entry was last updated on November 4, 2026; cite that date as the publication date. The primary sources listed above should be cited for the underlying facts.

APA
ColdCaseIndex. (2026, November 4). Nell Cropsey. https://coldcaseindex.com/cases/nell-cropsey-1901/
MLA
“Nell Cropsey.” ColdCaseIndex, 4 Nov. 2026, coldcaseindex.com/cases/nell-cropsey-1901/.
Wikipedia
{{cite web |url=https://coldcaseindex.com/cases/nell-cropsey-1901/ |title=Nell Cropsey |website=ColdCaseIndex |date=2026-11-04 |access-date=}}