Lottie Jo Gunn
Lottie Jo Gunn, a 16-year-old from Ohio, was found stabbed to death along Turner Valley Road in North Huntingdon Township, Pennsylvania, on May 24, 1985. The case went unsolved for 41 years. On November 5, 2026, Westmoreland County detectives arrested James Kruczek, 61, of West Mifflin, on a charge of criminal homicide after DNA from her clothing was matched to him; he has pleaded not guilty and was ordered to stand trial after a preliminary hearing on November 13, 2026.
- Status
- Arrest Made
- Type
- Homicide
- Date
- May 24, 1985
- Location
- North Huntingdon, Pennsylvania
- Age
- 16
- Gender
- Female
- Decade
- 1980s
- Open
- Partly resolved
- Charges or trialArrest Made
- Closed
A person has been arrested or charged. They are presumed innocent unless convicted.
Case background and investigation
On May 24, 1985, the Friday of Memorial Day weekend, the body of a teenage girl was found along Turner Valley Road in North Huntingdon Township, Westmoreland County. She had been stabbed several times in the abdomen and her death was ruled a homicide. She was later identified as Lottie Jo Gunn, 16, of Ohio.
The FBI and police in Akron, Ohio, determined that Gunn was one of several young runaways who had been drawn into an interstate prostitution ring, KDKA Radio reported. No one was charged with her killing, and the case stayed open for four decades.
According to the Westmoreland County District Attorney's Office, tips to the office and advances in DNA testing revived the investigation. An acquaintance told investigators that in the spring of 1985 James Kruczek had said he picked up a girl, killed her and left her body in the Coulter area of North Huntingdon Township. Detectives obtained Kruczek's DNA with a search warrant, and laboratory testing matched it to DNA on the dress Gunn was wearing, prosecutors said.
County detectives arrested Kruczek, 61, of West Mifflin, and District Attorney Nicole Ziccarelli announced a single count of criminal homicide on November 5, 2026, saying it had taken 41 years to reach that point. He was jailed without bail in the Westmoreland County Prison.
At a preliminary hearing on November 13, 2026, three witnesses testified in about 35 minutes. Glassport Police Chief Shawn DeVerse, who knew Kruczek in high school, testified that Kruczek told him in the 1980s that he had killed a girl who tried to "rip him off" and dumped her body near where Gunn was found. Kruczek's attorney entered a not guilty plea and said his client maintains he never met Gunn. The judge held the case for court, and formal arraignment is scheduled for December 23, 2026. Kruczek is presumed innocent unless proven guilty.
Timeline
-
May 24, 1985A teenage girl is found stabbed to death along Turner Valley Road in North Huntingdon Township, Pennsylvania; she is later identified as Lottie Jo Gunn, 16, of Ohio.
-
November 5, 2026Westmoreland County District Attorney Nicole Ziccarelli announces the arrest of James Kruczek, 61, of West Mifflin, on one count of criminal homicide after DNA on Gunn's clothing is matched to him.
-
November 13, 2026After a preliminary hearing with three witnesses, the case is held for court; Kruczek pleads not guilty and remains jailed without bail.
-
December 23, 2026Scheduled formal arraignment in Westmoreland County.
Sources
References used for this entry. ColdCaseIndex is an index of public information. To report an error, email info@coldcaseindex.com.
- Westmoreland County District Attorney - County Detectives make arrest in 41-year-old homicide case involving stabbing of 16-year-old girl
- CBS Pittsburgh - Pennsylvania man arrested in 16-year-old Ohio girl's death, closing 1985 cold case
- CBS Pittsburgh - Pennsylvania man arrested for 1985 cold case killing of 16-year-old Ohio girl appears in court
- KDKA Radio - Westmoreland Co. Police make arrest in over 40-year-old cold case
Have information about this case?
Cold cases are solved when someone comes forward. Even a detail that seems minor can matter. Contact law enforcement through one of these channels:
- FBI Tips (tips.fbi.gov): submit a tip online to the Federal Bureau of Investigation
- FBI tip line: 1-800-CALL-FBI (1-800-225-5324)
- The police force or sheriff's office responsible for North Huntingdon
Tips can usually be given anonymously. ColdCaseIndex does not collect tips. To report an error on this page, email info@coldcaseindex.com.
Entry last updated November 16, 2026.
Cite this entry
Permalink: https://coldcaseindex.com/cases/lottie-jo-gunn-1985/. This entry was last updated on November 16, 2026; cite that date as the publication date. The primary sources listed above should be cited for the underlying facts.
- APA
- ColdCaseIndex. (2026, November 16). Lottie Jo Gunn. https://coldcaseindex.com/cases/lottie-jo-gunn-1985/
- MLA
- “Lottie Jo Gunn.” ColdCaseIndex, 16 Nov. 2026, coldcaseindex.com/cases/lottie-jo-gunn-1985/.
- Wikipedia
{{cite web |url=https://coldcaseindex.com/cases/lottie-jo-gunn-1985/ |title=Lottie Jo Gunn |website=ColdCaseIndex |date=2026-11-16 |access-date=}}
Other cases in Pennsylvania
All 18 Pennsylvania cases →Similar cases
Cases of the same type and era, or sharing a distinctive theme with this one.