Conviction November 15, 2004 Homicide

Peter & Joan Porco

Peter Porco, 52, was killed and his wife Joan was severely injured in an axe attack at their home in Delmar, New York, on November 15, 2004. Their son Christopher Porco was convicted in 2006 of second-degree murder and attempted murder and sentenced to 50 years to life. He maintains his innocence, and a motion to vacate the conviction filed in 2023 was still pending in 2025.

Status
Conviction
Type
Homicide
Date
November 15, 2004
Location
Delmar, New York
Victims
Multiple
Decade
2000s
Where the case stands
  1. Open
  2. Partly resolved
  3. Charges or trial
  4. ClosedConviction

At least one person was convicted in connection with the case.

Timeline to scale
Each dot is a dated event below; the distance between dots is elapsed time. The darker dot marks the incident.
November 14, 2004: Campus video shows Christopher Porco's Jeep leaving the University of Rochester late at night.November 15, 2004: Peter and Joan Porco are attacked with an axe at home in Delmar; Peter dies of his injuries.August 10, 2006: An Orange County jury convicts him of second-degree murder and attempted second-degree murder.December 12, 2006: He is sentenced to 50 years to life.March 2010: The Appellate Division, Third Department, affirms the conviction.October 2011: The New York Court of Appeals affirms the conviction.April 2012: The U.S. Supreme Court declines to hear the case.January 12, 2023: Defense attorneys file a CPL 440.10 motion to vacate the conviction.February 2025: Because of a conflict of interest, the Schenectady County DA takes over the state's response to the motion.2004202520 years from incident to latest development
New York
52 cases in New York. Select any state to browse its cases.
AlaskaAKMaineMEWisconsinWIVermontVTNew HampshireNHWashingtonWAIdahoIDMontanaMTNorth DakotaNDMinnesotaMNIllinoisILMichiganMINew YorkNYMassachusettsMAOregonORNevadaNVWyomingWYSouth DakotaSDIowaIAIndianaINOhioOHPennsylvaniaPANew JerseyNJConnecticutCTRhode IslandRICaliforniaCAUtahUTColoradoCONebraskaNEMissouriMOKentuckyKYWest VirginiaWVVirginiaVAMarylandMDDelawareDEArizonaAZNew MexicoNMKansasKSArkansasARTennesseeTNNorth CarolinaNCSouth CarolinaSCDistrict of ColumbiaDCOklahomaOKLouisianaLAMississippiMSAlabamaALGeorgiaGAHawaiiHITexasTXFloridaFL

Early on November 15, 2004, Peter and Joan Porco were attacked with an axe in their bedroom at their home in Delmar, in the town of Bethlehem near Albany, New York. According to Wikipedia's summary of the trial record, Peter Porco, 52, was struck repeatedly in the head. He lived for several hours afterward before dying of his injuries. Joan Porco survived but lost an eye and part of her skull and was left with serious facial injuries.

According to CBS News and trial accounts, Bethlehem police Detective Christopher Bowdish testified that he asked the gravely injured Joan whether a family member had done this. He said she nodded when asked about her younger son, Christopher, and shook her head when asked about her older son, Johnathan. After she came out of a medically induced coma, Joan said she had no memory of the attack. She has maintained that Christopher is innocent and has continued to support him.

Prosecutors built a circumstantial case. According to CBS News and Wikipedia, campus security video showed Christopher's yellow Jeep leaving the University of Rochester late on November 14 and returning the next morning. Toll records and toll-collector accounts placed a vehicle on the Thruway between Rochester and Albany overnight, and a neighbor testified that he saw a yellow Jeep in the Porco driveway. The home's telephone line had been cut. Prosecutors argued that money was the motive, pointing to loans that Christopher had obtained by forging his father's signature. CBS News noted that no forensic evidence tied him to the scene.

Because of pretrial publicity, the trial was moved to Orange County. On August 10, 2006, the jury found Christopher Porco guilty of second-degree murder and attempted second-degree murder. On December 12, 2006, he was sentenced to 25 years to life on each count, served consecutively, for a total of 50 years to life. The Appellate Division affirmed the conviction in 2010, the New York Court of Appeals affirmed it in 2011, and the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear the case in 2012, according to Wikipedia.

On January 12, 2023, Porco's attorneys filed a motion to vacate the conviction under CPL 440.10, according to the law firm Barket Epstein. The motion alleges ineffective assistance of counsel, suppression of evidence and due process violations, and seeks DNA testing. CBS6 Albany reported in 2025 that the Schenectady County District Attorney's office had taken over the case because of a conflict of interest in the Albany County office, and that the motion was still pending before Judge William Little. No ruling had been found as of September 2026.

  1. November 14, 2004
    Campus video shows Christopher Porco's Jeep leaving the University of Rochester late at night.
  2. November 15, 2004
    Peter and Joan Porco are attacked with an axe at home in Delmar; Peter dies of his injuries.
  3. August 10, 2006
    An Orange County jury convicts him of second-degree murder and attempted second-degree murder.
  4. December 12, 2006
    He is sentenced to 50 years to life.
  5. March 2010
    The Appellate Division, Third Department, affirms the conviction.
  6. October 2011
    The New York Court of Appeals affirms the conviction.
  7. April 2012
    The U.S. Supreme Court declines to hear the case.
  8. January 12, 2023
    Defense attorneys file a CPL 440.10 motion to vacate the conviction.
  9. February 2025
    Because of a conflict of interest, the Schenectady County DA takes over the state's response to the motion.

About this entry

This case is recorded as conviction and is kept in the index for its historical and investigative significance. At least one person was convicted in connection with the case.

To report an error on this page, email info@coldcaseindex.com.

Entry last updated November 16, 2026.

Cite this entry

Permalink: https://coldcaseindex.com/cases/peter-joan-porco-2004/. This entry was last updated on November 16, 2026; cite that date as the publication date. The primary sources listed above should be cited for the underlying facts.

APA
ColdCaseIndex. (2026, November 16). Peter & Joan Porco. https://coldcaseindex.com/cases/peter-joan-porco-2004/
MLA
“Peter & Joan Porco.” ColdCaseIndex, 16 Nov. 2026, coldcaseindex.com/cases/peter-joan-porco-2004/.
Wikipedia
{{cite web |url=https://coldcaseindex.com/cases/peter-joan-porco-2004/ |title=Peter & Joan Porco |website=ColdCaseIndex |date=2026-11-16 |access-date=}}